My Evening of Epic Fails (Or I Screw Up My First Attempt at Cake Pops)

“I don’t think people understand what you’re saying when you say Albus.” My mother said as she sipped her sauvignon blanc.

“Well, that’s why I introduce him as Albus Dumbledore,” I replied.

“Not everyone knows who that is.”

“Of course they do. Albus is a mighty wizard!” I exclaimed indignantly. “Besides, it’s Latin for ‘white.’ I like Latin.” (I did NOT like Latin when I was translating the entire Aeneid into English, but this is not important now.)

“I think they think you’re saying Elvis.”

This from the woman who named me Anika? I’ve been called everything from Anita to Shaniqua over the years, and I’ve been correcting people on the pronunciation of my name since Kindergarten, so she hardly has a foot to stand on when it comes to weird names for offspring – human or dog.

“Well, I nearly named him Chappy Sinclair, but I changed my mind at the last minute.”

By look on her face, it was clear this name would not have met with her standards either. (She does not appreciate Iron Eagle any more than Harry Potter, apparently.)

She’s actually right that people have called my dog everything from “Alvin” to “Elvis,” but I had no intention of conceding this. The little girl downstairs squeals, “Elbis!” every time she sees him. (Even this hybrid is probably toddler for Elvis.)

I should also mention that she doesn’t approve of Woodley’s name either. She thinks it’s confusing I named a fluffy female after a 265-pound linebacker. She’s probably not wrong.

She may have given me a hard time about my dogs’ names, but she did buy me this fabulous pink cake pop pan from Sur La Table, so there’s that.

My fancy new cake pop pan, courtesy of my mother.

I must say, my first attempt at using my new toy was even more disastrous than my attempts at dog-naming.

I was hoping to make Hedwig-like owls that looked like this:

See these perfect owls from Bakerella? Yeah, mine looked nothing like them.

I didn’t even get to the decorating part, because I ended up with THIS mess.

Albus is ignoring the Chernobyl-like disaster in the foreground and heading straight for the un-sullied cake pops on the counter. Even my dog doesn’t think the others are edible.

I think my first mistake was using a strawberry cake mix for the cake pops, as it was not nearly dense enough. (I’m starting to believe “cake” is a bit of a misnomer and the base of these balls is really more of a cake/cookie lovechild.) My next mistake was purchasing Ghirardelli white chocolate chips to coat my cake-y creations. Despite adding shortening to make the melted mess thinner, it was just too thick and sticky to properly coat the crumbly cake.

Desperate to find another coating substance, I scoured the internet this morning and discovered another option on Bakerella. It turns out it was hidden within another one of my pins. (Oops. I probably should have READ the post first instead of simply pinning the photo at first sight.) Bakerella suggests using Merckens Candy Coating for the pops. I guess I’ll be looking for a new cake pop recipe and then dipping those in Merckens next time.

I’m not really sure what to do with my cake pop rejects. I’m leaning toward feeding them to the squirrels downstairs even if they are the sworn enemies of my poorly named dogs.

Oh, and don’t get me started on what went wrong with THIS watermelon shark carving last night….

This Jedi-eating watermelon monster was supposed to be a shark. Alas, my Shun Sumo Santoku knife was just too big for the finer details.

Have you tried making cake pops? Did you make an epic mess like me?

10 thoughts on “My Evening of Epic Fails (Or I Screw Up My First Attempt at Cake Pops)

  1. I have not made them myself, but urban legends have been known to circulate that brownie pops work better, particularly of the dense, fudgy variety. Also of rumored success: use a cakey doughnut recipe, and dip the stick in melted chocolate before skewering the doughnut ball (then let the chocolate cool and set inside the cake while resting horizontally before turning upright.) And then invite me over, as I’m not likely to discriminate against any cake product based upon aesthetics and I’ll bring the Kim Crawford. Just saying. 🙂

  2. Ok, first I personally love that you named your dog after Dumbledore 🙂

    Secondly, I give you a lot of credit for attempting cake pops! I am personally scared silly of trying my hand at those. I wish you much success in your next attempt!

    And finally, I say embrace that you made a Sarlacc instead of a shark (and yes, I am a geek and went and Wikipedia’ed the name of the monster out of curiosity). Next step is to carve a watermelon into Jabba’s ship and have fun throwing action figures into the mouth of the monster!

    • It is rather Sarlacc-like, isn’t it? I LOVE that you looked it up! And Cake pops are truly frightening. You are wise to steer clear of them. I am a little too Luke-like to shy away from certain disaster in the kitchen. As Yoda would say, “Told you I did. Reckless is he….”

  3. Pingback: Of Owls and Strollers (Or I’m Planning a Baby Shower) « Dogs, Dishes, and Decor

  4. Pingback: My Rotting Veggies Reek (Or How to Fix a Wet Compost Bin) « Dogs, Dishes, and Decor

  5. Pingback: Playing with Candy (Or How to Dip and Decorate Marshmallows) « Dogs, Dishes, and Decor

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s